Pages

Total Pageviews

Friday, March 29, 2019

What is the problem of personal identity as it relates to posthumanism? Do you find Bostrom's answer to this problem persuasive? Why or why not?

     Topic:Summary and Analysis of Bostrom's"Why I want to be Posthuman When Grow Up"



The Reality of Posthumanism

Bostrom “posthuman” evaluated in certain categories. I will summarize these categories with a single narration. First of all, I start with the definition of posthuman concept. The Posthuman is described in different ways by many different authors. According to Bostrom,Posthuman; defined as an entity with posthuman capacity. Bostrom mentions that there are three general central capacities of people. These are health span, cognition and emotion. In other words, people's development of these concepts and extreme human development, which is at a different point than the people in the lives of these people, can lead to posthuman forms of existence. As a posthuman capacity, I would like to say that a general centralized capacity exceeds the maximum value that can be reached by any existing human being without exceeding the new technological means. However, Bostrom claims that there are 5 levels of objection against posthumanism. These are the appeal levels: It can not be done, Too difficult / expensive, It would be too bad for the community, Postthuman lives would be worse than human lives, Not benefited.

 Bortrom states that all of these levels are negative and impossible for posthuman views. People's lives are happy or unhappy, tragic or entertaining in every way, no matter how people live in the last moments of people are trying to live more. As the problems that the human body cannot fight, slow down of metabolism, like weakening and aging of the body structure, people realize that they are approaching death. Therefore, the hope of living a little more in the last days of their lives to be able to compensate for a lot of things and begin to appreciate every moment of their lives. The most important reason for people's desire to be a posthuman indicates that the health period is due to their desire to live a longer and healthier life. People want to live without health problems at almost any age. Bostrom forms prima facie support for claiming that extended life is not entirely healthy. Bostrom mentions that this is an option worth having. It is a known fact that people always seek to develop cognition. Every person wants to have high cognitive capacity. Bostrom mentions that people who have high cognitive capacity want to develop their cognitive capacity and want to come to posthuman point more than people with low cognitive capacity.

Bostrom also argues that the level of cognitive abilities at the posthuman level will be perfect, and that the development of emotional development will become more complex. Bostrom mentions about how broad and comprehensive a person's emotional capacity can reach the highest level of cognitive capacity. According to Bostrom, the fact that a person has any of the 3 general capacities (health span, cognition and emotion) seems to be reasonable to be able to question one's self, life and everything more, and determine the most important goals that she/he can reach and move forward towards that purpose. Bostrom also mentions the importance of one's personal identity. The person's status as Posthuman is different in a significant way. Bostrom explained this with an example. For example, suppose one born as a posthuman. Imagine his/her life, his/her cognitive abilities are perfect. We try and be like him/her. But our innate talents, emotions and everything we have says that there will be no posthuman. So here is what Bostrom is talking about that each person has his/her own personal identity and that we cannot know whether we will be good or bad according to the posthuman.

There is always a good concept of living by the nature of people. This concept of life can be counted under many different titles such as social status, necessities, habits, love, feelings, dreams, psychological process. However, people always forget to live some of these concepts because they are in the effort to reach the most perfect, or they may not understand these concepts. As a result, Bostrom claims that some people are extremely helpful and should not die. The development of 3 central capacities, such as cognition, healthspan, and emotional, suggests that posthuman levels may be achieved and may be applicable to some concept. But he argues that people aren't posthuman now. When people understand what the human concept means, the view defended by Bostrom will prove his justification for the fact that the human species is a very valuable species.



 I think that personal identity cannot be the same with posthumanism. Because even if a person develops all 3 central capacities he / she has, I still think that a very small part of one's memories, goals, skills and psychological characteristics can change. In general, however, I think that the person will continue to have many of her/his memories, desires, tendencies, personal relationships and social connections that he/she possesses his personal identity. Bostrom's statements on this subject were convincing for me. Because when a person has a personal identity, it is not easy to change her/him. For example, someone who lost mother or father. Let them think that you love and imagine them every day. Let us assume later that this person has reached the Posthuman level. After the posthuman, Can we say that the same person can stop thinking and loving them? I say absolutely that “no”. I mean, it is a very difficult and profound process to change our personal identity. I don't think even a person who has reached the posthuman level can easily change it.

                                                     Written by Erdogan Akbiyik

http://erdoganakbiyik.blogspot.com/
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCDsUnmBfVdEPkcC8FlzPKcg

No comments:

Post a Comment